Song of the Bandits – Full Review

October 25, 2023

Song of the Bandits - Unspoiled Review

Kdrama and Ramen

For the love of all things Kdrama

News and Reviews

Song of the Bandits – Full Review

This is a full review and contains

 Spoilers!

Song of the Bandits - Unspoiled Review

Song of the Bandits - Full Review

 

Welcome to  Song of the Bandits - Full Review.  A train heist in Gando territory leads an unlikely group on a crazy journey to get funds into the hands of Korean freedom fighters. If you haven't watched this drama yet, I recommend checking out my unspoiled review here.

Song of the Bandits

Aired:  September 22, 2023

# of Episodes:  9

Where to Watch: Netflix

Genre: Historical Action Drama

Starring:  Kim Nam Gil and Seo Hyun

Song of the Bandits - Unspoiled Review

The Story

 

Song of the Bandits - Full Review

In the 1920's, many displaced Koreans made their way north to Gando.  In a territory full of outlaws and desperate poverty, a rumor of a suitcase of money traveling through the area by train draws the attention of many, hoping to steal the money and finally strike it rich.  Among them is one brave activist, who lives posing as a Japanese government employee.  She intends to take all of the money and deliver it into the hands of the Korean army for independence.  And she will enlist the help of a hardened gun for hire and a jaded leader of bandits to get the money safely delivered to those who need it most.  

Song of the Bandits - Unspoiled Review

The Leads

 

Song of the Bandits - Full Review
Song of the Bandits - Full Review

Kim Nam Gil as Lee Yoon

Lee Yoon was a slave before his master freed him to serve with him in the Japanese army.  But taking the lives of fellow Koreans left Yoon feeling guilty and ashamed.  So he resigned his position to surrender his life to one of the men whose family he had killed.  But instead of demanding his death, the stranger challenges Yoon to live his life atoning for his crimes.  So Yoon becomes the leader of a band of bandits fighting to keep their freedom in the rough territory of Gando.  When the woman he has loved from afar for his whole life shows up in Gando, trying to smuggle money to the freedom fighters there, he risks his life and reputation to protect her and her precious cargo.  

Song of the Bandits - Full Review

Between his time as a slave and his time as a trained killer for the Japanese, Lee Yoon has plenty of things in his past that he isn't proud of.  But when he becomes the leader of the bandits, he gets a chance to do something good for himself and his people.  And his relief when he finds out that, despite appearances, he and Hee Shin are actually on the same side, is obvious.  Kim Nam Gil is an outstanding actor and I wish we could have had more episodes to get to know this complex character.  This role definitely had a lot of potential, but there isn't enough development there to give Kim Nam Gil much to work with.  

Seo Hyun as Nam Hee Shin

Nam Hee Shin works for the Japanese Government as the Head of the Railway Bureau.  She is also dating Lee Kwang Il, the one time-owner and sometimes friend of Yoon.  But in secret, Hee Shin is actually an activist for Korean Independence.  Her job and her romantic relationship with Kwang Il both give her opportunities to collect sensitive information and pass it on to the freedom fighters.  So when she is asked to deliver a suitcase full of money from the Japanese Government to the Chinese in Gando, to pay for a railway project, she makes plans to steal the funds and deliver them into the hands of the Korean rebels.  But when her life is threatened by countless outlaws all interested in stealing the money, she finds an unlikely ally in the taciturn Korean bandit, Yoon.  And he seems like her only chance to get the money safely into Korean hands.  

Song of the Bandits - Full Review

Nam Hee Shin is a wealthy woman of privilege who could easily have hidden behind her job working with the Japanese.  But her heart breaks when she thinks about all her people have endured under the weight of Japanese and Chinese oppression.  And when she arrives in Gando and sees it for herself firsthand, she is even more determined to help the freedom fighters' cause.  Seo Hyun did a fine job with this role, although I found this character to be a bit dull, especially when compared with the vibrant personality of Eon Nyeon Yi.  I wish we had seen some other sides to her character that weren't so stiff and proper all the time.  

Song of the Bandits - Full Review

Supporting Characters

 

Song of the Bandits - Full Review
Song of the Bandits - Full Review

Lee Hyun Wook as Lee Kwang Il

When Yoon was a slave, Lee Kwang Il was his master.  But when Kwang Il decided to enlist with the Japanese army, he freed Yoon and asked him to join him.  At times, Kwang Il almost seems to have a brotherly affection for Yoon, but he often abandons that affection in the face of greed and fear.  Now Kwang Il is a major in the 37th Infantry Regimen of the Japanese Imperialist Army.  And when he learns that Yoon has abandoned the Japanese to fight alongside the Korean Independence fighters, Kwang Il immediately considers him an enemy who must be stopped at all costs.  

Lee Ho Jung as Eon Nyeon Yi

Eon Nyeon Yi is a gun for hire who is initially hired by Kwang Il to kill Yoon.  But when Yoon tells her he is on his way to die at the hands of someone he owes a debt, she lets him go, assuming he will die anyway.  Later she is hired by Hee Shin to help her get the money safely off the train and into rebel hands.  But while working with Hee Shin, she is shocked to cross paths with a very much alive Yoon.  Now, with her reputation on the line, her goal is to complete her work with Hee Shin and then go back to finish Yoon off.  But her loyalties are tested as she works side by side with Yoon protecting Hee Shin and the people living under Choi Chung Soo.

Song of the Bandits - Full Review
Song of the Bandits - Full Review

Yoo Jae Myung as Choi Chung Soo

Choi Chung Soo is the head of a small Korean village that hides up in the hills of Gando.  He is determined to protect both the land the people living with him.  His family was killed by Yoon during a military massacre, but instead of demanding revenge, he challenges Yoon to join their community and atone for his crimes by protecting them.  Choi Chung Soo helps Yoon lead the bandit group and his specialty is using a bow and arrow.  

Things I Liked

 

 ♥ Western Concept

The way they turned 1920's Manchuria into the wild west for this drama was fascinating.  From saloon gunfights to train heists, this drama captured the essence of it all, while still giving it an authentic kdrama feel.  I love this concept and I think they did a great job with it.  From the gritty scenery to the whistling soundtrack, it really felt like I was watching an old spaghetti western.  While the story may have fallen short in my opinion, the look and sound of this drama was sweeping and beautiful.  

 ♥ Female Gunslinger

I love Kim Nam Gil and he played a perfect outlaw gunslinger, but the character of Eon Nyeon Yi was such a surprising breath of fresh air.  While the idea of a female outlaw isn't wholly unique, Nyeon Yi's unapologetically rough exterior felt honest and real.  I mean, why leave all the chaotic fight scenes to the guys? Through the whole drama, Hee Shin remains the calm and collected lady, but Nyeon Yi represents a feistier, self-sufficient side to feminism that is much appreciated.

♥ Historical Context

I always love a drama that gives us a look at periods or locations that don't get talked about often in dramas.  In this case, the history lesson about a place like Gando, that, according to Yoon is made up of "Chinese land, Japanese money, and Joseon's people" was interesting and new to me.  Although we don't see much of the Chinese perspective, the mix of peoples and cultures created a unique blend.  

Song of the Bandits - Full Review

Things I Didn't Like

 

Violence

While I am not particularly squeamish, this drama definitely went overkill on the violence and gore.  Most kdrama fans are already aware of Netflix' tendency to add American shock value into all of their dramas, whether that be sex or violence. But this one was much more bloody than I expected.  And sure, a little violence is to be expected in a "Western", but this one seemed to go a bit overboard for my taste.   

Kwang Il

Kwang Il's character had so much potential, but I felt like I didn't know how we should feel about him.  At times, he seems to feel some sentimental attachment to Yoon and their memories together.  But other times his hatred and resentment seems more deep-seated than just a military enemy or a romantic competitor.  We really just scratched the surface of all Kwang Il seems to think and feel.  

Lack of Development

This story seemed to jump all over the place, leaving so many ideas and characters unfinished.  I suppose there is always a possibility that Netflix will wave the wand and give fans a second season, although I'm not sure this cast would be willing to sign on even if it was offered. But as it sits for now, I feel like the plot lacked both proper development and a satisfying ending.  

Song of the Bandits - Full Review

The Ending

 

I don't know why, but from what I had heard, I expected "Song of the Bandits" to have a happy ending.  Boy, was I wrong!  Yoon and Kwang Il finally face off, and although Yoon ends up with the advantage, he settles for shooting Kwang Il's trigger finger off rather than actually killing him.  Yoon and his band withdraw to safety and the Japanese forces report their failure back to the higher ups.  Kwang Il is demoted and returns to Hee Shin a broken man.  But things only get worse when he finds out that Hee Shin has been working with the Independence Fighters the whole time.  Yoon plans to visit Hee Shin, but a boy delivers a note to him from Hee Shin warning him that he must stay away.  The drama ends with Hee Shin getting married to Kwang Il, despite her betrayal and love for Yoon.  And Yoon and the bandits have regrouped to fight yet more Japanese troops.  

Song of the Bandits - Full Review

Should I Watch

 

Song of the Bandits - Unspoiled Review

"Song of the Bandits" is the Korean equivalent of a spaghetti western, in this case happening in the rugged territory of Gando, or Manchuria.  If you have been following many Netlfix kdramas, it will not surprise you that this one is excessively violent.  While the music and cinematography is sweeping and beautiful, the storyline is muddled and incomplete.  And I don't seem to be the only one to think so, since the actors have given interviews to voice their own displeasure at the finished product.  If you are looking for a series full of gun fights and action, and don't mind a lot of blood, you may enjoy this one.  The action is thrilling and well filmed, and the drama does look and sound impressive.  But don't expect to fall in love with the story, the romance, or the ending.  If you haven't seen it yet, I would put this one on the back burner and watch "Mr. Sunshine" instead...or again!    I give "The Song of Bandits" a 7 out of 10 ramen.

🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜

See other full reviews here:

Start Up 2020 Full Review

Air Dates: October 17  - December 6, 2020 Episodes: 16 Where to Watch: Netflix Genre: Romantic Drama Starring: Bae Suzy and Nam Joo HyukSandbox is a program designed to help start-up IT companies get their businesses of the ground.  Participants are chosen through a...

Empress Ki 2013 Full Review

Air Dates: October 28 - April 29, 2014 Episodes: 51 Where to Watch: Kocowa Genre: Historical Romance Starring: Ha Ji Won and Ji Chang WookDuring the Yuan dynasty, the Mongols ruled a large portion of Asia, including Goryeo (modern day Korea).  Empress Ki follows the...

More Than Friends 2020 Full Review

Air Dates: September 25 - November 28, 2020 Episodes: 16 Where to Watch: Viki Genre: Romantic Drama Starring: Ong Seong Wu and Shin Ye Eun The story of a young woman who has spent the last 10 years with a crush on the same guy.  Twice she has gotten up the nerve to...

Mom Has an Affair 2020 Full Review

Air Dates: May 4 - October 23, 2020 Episodes: 122 Where to Watch: Kocowa Genre: Family Melodrama Starring: Hyun Jyu Ni and Lee Jae HwangA single mom has spent her life struggling to make ends meet to provide for her family, while hoping to fulfill her dream of...

Record of Youth 2020 Full Review

Air Dates: September 7 - October 27, 2020 Episodes: 16 Where to Watch: Netflix Genre: Romantic Drama Starring: Park Bo Gum and Park So Dam  Enter the world of modelling and acting through the eyes of 2 young men who have spent their 20's waiting to catch their big...

Lie After Lie 2020 Full Review

Air Dates: September 4 - October 24, 2020 Episodes: 16 Where to Watch: Viki Genre: Romantic Melodrama Starring: Lee Yoo Ri and Yeon Jung Hoon  A young woman is wrongly imprisoned for the murder of her husband and gives up custody of her baby daughter to protect her. ...

Welcome2Life Full Review

Air Dates: August 5 - September 24, 2019 Episodes: 32 Where to Watch: Kocowa Genre: Romantic Fantasy Starring: Rain and Im Ji YeonLee Jae Sang is a prosecutor who has spent his career putting his own financial gain and winning record over people.  Even when it meant...

Do You Like Brahms 2020 Full Review

Air Dates: August 31 - October 20, 2020 Episodes: 16 Where to Watch: Viki Genre: Romantic Drama Starring: Park Eun Bin and Kim Min Jae"Do You Like Brahms" is about a group of students involved in an elite school of music at their university.   A struggling 4th year...

The King 2020 Full Review

Air Dates: April 17 - June 12, 2020 Episodes: 16 Where to Watch: Netflix Genre: Fantasy Romance Starring: Lee Min Ho and Kim Go EunLee Gon became the emperor of the Kingdom of Corea when his father was killed in front of him at the age of 8.  One night as the emperor...

Flower of Evil 2020 Full Review

Air Dates: July 29 - September 23, 2020 Episodes: 16 Where to Watch: Genre: Crime Thriller Starring: Lee Joon Gi and Moon Chae Won  Baek Hee Sung seems like the perfect husband and father.  But he hides a dark secret from his past.  His father, Do Min Seok was a cruel...

Join My

Newsletter!

Related Posts

June 1, 2026

Start Up 2020 Full Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Spoiler-Free Review Series Details […]

June 1, 2026

Start Up 2020 Spoiler-Free Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Full Review Series Details […]

June 1, 2026

New Premieres and Fun Finales in May 2026

Song of the Bandits – Full Review May 2026 Korean Drama Premieres […]

May 28, 2026

Empress Ki 2013 Full Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Spoiler-Free Review Series Details […]

May 28, 2026

Empress Ki 2013 Spoiler-Free Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Full Review Series Details […]

May 28, 2026

More Than Friends 2020 Full Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Spoiler-Free Review Series Details […]

May 28, 2026

More Than Friends 2020 Spoiler-Free Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Full Review Series Details […]

May 28, 2026

Mom Has an Affair 2020 Full Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Spoiler-Free Review Series Details […]

May 28, 2026

Mom Has an Affair 2020 Spoiler-Free Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Full Review Series Details […]

May 28, 2026

Lonely Enough to Love 2020 Full Review

Song of the Bandits – Full Review Read Spoiler-Free Review Series Details […]

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.