The Scholar Who Walks the Night – Full Review

 

Welcome to The Scholar Who Walks the Night -Full Review.  A Joseon guardian vampire fights to free the country from the evil clutches of a greedy vampire lord.  If you haven’t watched this drama yet, I recommend checking out my unspoiled review here.

The Scholar Who Walks the Night

Aired:  July 8 –  September 10, 2015

# of Episodes:  20

Where to Watch:  Viki

Genre:  Historical Vampire Drama

Starring:  Lee Joon Gi and Lee Yo Bi

.

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Unspoiled Review

The Story

 

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Kim Sung Yeol is a guardian vampire who has spent the last 120 years trying to avenge the death of his first love, which was caused by the evil vampire, Gwi.  During that 120 years, Gwi has been ruling the Joseon Empire from behind the scenes, by controlling the king and all his decisions.  Sung Yeol finds an unlikely ally in a struggling male book seller who turns out to be a female in disguise.  With her help, Sung Yeol hopes to find a missing book, written by the deceased Crown Prince, that gives a detailed strategy of how to defeat Gwi once and for all.  But Gwi is not going down without a fight!

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Unspoiled Review

The Leads

 

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review
The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Lee Joon Gi as Kim Sung Yeol

Kim Sung Yeol has a happy life as a scholar who is best friends with the Crown Prince, and is engaged to marry the woman he loves.  But that all changes when his fiancé’s death is caused by an evil vampire, Gwi, and Sung Yeol is chosen as the next guardian vampire.  Fast forward to the present;  for the last 120 years, Sung Yeol has been looking for  a way to get revenge for the loss of his first love.  Gwi is hidden safely in a lair under the palace, where he has controlled the country through his power over the king for over 100 years.  But while the Crown Prince was alive, he wrote a strategy for how Gwi could be defeated, and hid it in a book that Sung Yeol is searching for.  If he can find the book and get rid of Gwi, his job as guardian would be complete.

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Kim Sung Yeol lives his life hiding his true identity.  For that reason, he pretends to be cold and uninterested in the people around him.  In reality, he has lived his life in guilt about the death of his first love and anger at Gui for everything that has happened since.  Because of this guilt, even though he falls in love with Yang Seon, he denies his feelings because he doesn’t think he has the right to be happy.  Lee Joon Gi is convincing as the self-refective loner who carries the burden of the world on his shoulders.  I don’t think it’s his best role, but that has more to do with the script than his acting ability.

Lee Yoo Bi as  Jo Yang Seon

Jo Yang Seon’s father is framed for treason, which causes her family to lose everything.  To protect her from an unfortunate female lineage, her father has made her dress and act like a boy since she was young.  As a boy, she runs errands for her father and helps him sell books around the city.  When a  rich, private book buyer comes to her looking for an old manuscript, she is determined to succeed.  But as she gets to know the mysterious man, she begins to believe he could be the famous “Night Scholar” who is one of her favorite book heroes.  By the time she learns Sung Yeol’s true identity, her feelings have become too  strong to make her alter her course, no matter what dangers she may face because of him.

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Yang Seon has lived her life with the freedom of a male, while never being able to reveal her true identity, so she understands Sung Yeol’s feelings of having to live in hiding.  She is bold and adventurous, although that often gets her into more trouble than she can actually handle.  Lee Yoo Bi is okay in this role, although the character is a bit non-descript. The romantic storyline gets moved to the back burner about halfway through and that doesn’t leave much for Yang Seon to do.  There are still some sweet moments but they are less frequent as time goes on.

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Supporting Characters

 

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review
The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Shim Chang Min as Lee Yoon

Lee Yoon is the current Crown Prince, while his grandfather sits on the throne.  Resentful of the hold Gwi has on the country and specifically the royal court, he is also determined to find a way to defeat Gwi and remove him once and for all.  Eventually he teams up with Sung Yeol to try to get rid of Gwi and bring honor back to his family.

Lee Soo Hyuk as Gwi

Gwi is the evil, greedy vampire who hopes to one day do away with royal family all together, so that the kingdom will be his alone.  He will stop at nothing to maintain his power, including creating armies of vampires just so that he can play the hero by killing them.  

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review
The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Kim So Eun as Choi Hye Ryung

Choi Hye Ryung is one of Gwi’s secret weapons.  Her father is an official of the royal court who is helping Gwi.  Hye Ryung looks exactly like Sung Yeol’s dead fiancé, which Gwi plans to use to his advantage when the time comes.  But in the end, Hye Ryung marries the Crown Prince to gain her own power.

Things I Liked

 

♥ Lee Soo Hyuk as Gwi

For Lee Soo Hyuk’s character, they kept the dialogue to a minimum, which definitely worked in his favor.  Gwi’s facials expressions and body language were a highlight of this drama, and his lines, when he had them were few and sincere.  His absolute disdain for humankind was hilariously clear in every scene.  From bored eye rolls to fits of pure rage, Gwi’s feelings and motivations were always clear, and he never had to rely on internal monologues or over-the-top acting to make his point.

♥ Gwi and Sung Yeol

Some of the later interactions between Gwi and Sung Yeol were quite profound, as they wrestled with their regrets and purposes.  Though they were sworn enemies, in the end they weren’t so different.  Both craved love and acceptance and both resented the painful destiny they had been handed.  But Sung Yeol put all that aside to serve a larger purpose, which is what makes him the hero and Gwi the villain.

♥ Vampire Saeguk

Combining any horror element with historical dramas creates an interesting platform, as evidenced by other dramas like “Kingdom”.  It worked particularly well for vampires.  The flowing costumes and dark lighting really set an appropriate mood.  In concept, I really enjoyed the premise of this drama.  Visually  the whole series was well-designed and fun to watch.

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Things I Didn’t Like

 

Lost Chemistry

Lee Joon Gi and Lee Yoo Bi had some good report in the beginning of this drama.  Their scenes together had chemistry and suspense.  But once they both came to terms with their feelings for each other, I felt like the chemistry fizzled out.  Without any conflict, their relationship just wasn’t very interesting.  And how many times can they argue about who gets to die for the other?

 

The Middle

For me, “The Scholar Who Walks the Night” started off pretty good.  The characters were interesting, the love story was smoldery, and the concept grabbed my interest.  And really, the last couple episodes ended things on a high note for me.  But that middle section got bogged down.  The plot became chaotic and non-sensible at times and the characters lost their clarity.  I heard that the show was forced to bring in new writers partway through, which is probably why it struggled, but struggle it did.  

Who Needs a Book?

Ok, this was one of my biggest pet peeves with this storyline.  They make such a big deal over finding the hidden book with the amazing secret plan. But in the end, Sung Yeol discovers the power of Yang Seon’s blood on his own, when she uses some to save him.  And then the rest of the plan was, let’s go blow things up?  I just expected something with a little more finesse than bite the girl and blow the lair to smithereens.  The book was just a distraction with no real purpose, except to provide some temporary misunderstanding about Yang Seon being offered as a sacrifice.

 

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

The Ending

 

So, this is another one of those dramas that seems like it’s a happy ending, but still leaves some doubt, which as I’ve said before, are not my favorite.  Gwi and Sung Yeol have their epic battle and the lair comes crashing down on top of them just as the sun rises, burying them both.  Though the crew waits outside, neither vampire comes out alive.  Fast forward a year.  Su Hyang is back to running her gibang and Ho Jin uses the backroom to sell rare books until Sung Yeol “returns”.  Yoon has taken over as king but he still mourns Hye Ryung.  In his room, he proudly displays the sword he gave to Sung Yeol before the battle, which causes the first glimmer of hope in fans who are still hoping Sung Yeol is alive and well.  Yang Seon has gone back to teaching and writing, which is nice to see.  She walks home thinking of Sung Yeol and glances around her in hopes that he will be there.  And then, as if her thoughts conjured him, Sung Yeol is there in front of her.  He apologizes for being late and she answers that she was prepared to wait another 50 years.  They kiss and then the two of them seem to vanish into thin air.  So was this a dream?  Was he really there?  I guess that is up to you to decide.

The Scholar Who Walks the Night - Full Review

Should I Watch

 

The Scholar Who Walks the Night

“The Scholar Who Walks the Night” is a great option for all you vampire drama fans out there.  Sexy vampires are in abundance in this interesting take on Joseon history.  The drawback is that the script can be kind of a mess at times.  If you are someone who looks for a tight plot line with no glaring holes, you should skip this one.  While the cast boasts a lot of familiar faces, with obvious acting skills, the script can be ackward and unnecessarily wordy.  Dramas have come a long way since 2015, so the effects can seem a bit cheesy given their age. But if you want a vampire adventure story with a sweet romance and some amazing sageuk costumes,  this is a good choice.  And did I mention hot vampires?     I give “The Scholar Who Walks the Night” a 7 out of 10 ramen.

🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜

See other full reviews here:

A Comprehensive Look at Family By Choice 2024

Explore every aspect of 'Family By Choice' in this comprehensive review. Dive into character insights, strengths, and weaknesses. If you haven't seen the drama yet and are looking for a spoiler-free review, check out the link below.Warning: This review contains major...

A Comprehensive Look at The Judge from Hell 2024

Join us as we dive deep into the thrilling and chilling world of Sweet Home. This review covers Seasons 1-3, providing comprehensive insights and detailed analysis.In "A Comprehensive Look at The Judge from Hell 2024", join us as we dive deep into the dramatic world...

A Comprehensive Look at Love Next Door 2024

Delve into the emotional love story of 'Love Next Door' with this in-depth review. Explore the characters, their stories, and the highlights of this fun historical rom-com.   If you haven't watched this drama yet and would prefer a spoiler-free review, please click on...

A Comprehensive Look at Gyeongseong Creature 1 and 2

Explore every aspect of 'Gyeongseong Creature' in this comprehensive review. Dive into character insights, strengths, and weaknesses. If you haven't seen the drama yet and are looking for a spoiler-free review, check out the link below.Air Date:  December 22, 2023 -...

A Comprehensive Look at No Gain No Love 2024

Explore every aspect of 'No Gain No Love' in this comprehensive review. Dive into character insights, strengths, and weaknesses. If you haven't seen the drama yet and are looking for a spoiler-free review, check out the link below.Warning: This review contains major...

A Comprehensive Look at Good Partner 2024

Join us as we dive deep into the thrilling and chilling world of Sweet Home. This review covers Seasons 1-3, providing comprehensive insights and detailed analysis.In "A Comprehensive Look at Good Partner 2024", join us as we dive deep into the dramatic world of 'Good...

A Comprehensive Look at Knight Flower 2024

Delve into the emotional love story of 'Knight Flower' with this in-depth review. Explore the characters, their stories, and the highlights of this fun historical rom-com.   If you haven't watched this drama yet and would prefer a spoiler-free review, please click on...

A Comprehensive Look at Black Out 2024

Explore every aspect of 'Black Out' in this comprehensive review. Dive into character insights, strengths, and weaknesses. If you haven't seen the drama yet and are looking for a spoiler-free review, check out the link below.Air Date: August 16, - October 4, 2024...

A Comprehensive Look at My Demon 2023

Join us as we dive deep into the thrilling and chilling world of Sweet Home. This review covers Seasons 1-3, providing comprehensive insights and detailed analysis.In "A Comprehensive Look at My Demon 2023", join us as we dive deep into the dramatic world of 'My...

A Complete Look at Romance in the House 2024

Join us as we dive deep into the dramatic world of 'Romance in the House', exploring its plot, character arcs, and unforgettable moments.  If you haven't seen 'Romance in the House' yet and would prefer a spoiler-free summary of the story, please click on the link...