Kdrama and Ramen
For the love of all things KdramaNews and Reviews
This is a full review and contains
Spoilers!
Tale of the Nine-Tailed 1938 – Full Review
Welcome to Tale of the Nine-Tailed 1938 – Full Review. A nine-tailed fox goes back to the year 1938 to retrieve an important magic artifact. If you haven’t watched this drama yet, I recommend checking out my unspoiled review here.
Tale of the Nine-Tailed 1938
♥ Aired: May 6 – June 11, 2023
♥# of Episodes: 12
♥Where to Watch: Amazon Prime
♥Genre: Historical Fantasy
♥Starring: Lee Dong Wook and Kim So Yeon
The Story
A handsome gumiho mountain god is sent back in time to retreat a precious magical stone and bring it back to the present for safe keeping. Along his journey, he will be reunited with many familiar faces, including his 2 childhood best friends and his younger brother. But he isn’t the only one who wants the stone. He will encounter powerful enemies and try to recruit trusted allies in his task, so that he can safely return home to the present and to the wife that he has promised to love until the end of their days.
The Leads
Lee Dong Wook as Lee Yeon
After living decades just passing the time away, Lee Yeon is finally happy living as a devoted husband in the present. But when the magical guardian stone is stolen, Taluipa sends him back to the year 1938 to retrieve it. Now stuck in the past, Yeon is given the opportunity to spend more time with his brother Rang, who sacrificed his own life to save Yeon. He also meets up with his childhood best friends. But their reunion becomes complicated when Yeon discovers that Moo Young was the man in the red and white mask who stole the stone in the first place. And now that he is back in 1938, he will meet other evil spirits who also want to steal the guardian stone for themselves. And Yeon’s time is limited because if he doesn’t make it back before the lunar eclipse, he will stuck in the past forever and never see his wife again.
Lee Yeon is a loyal and devoted friend, husband, and brother. He is also egotistical and stubborn. His inability to give up on any of the people that he cares about is one of the things that makes him such a charming character. And years of loneliness has taught him the value of relationships and companionship. Lee Dong Wook has brought this wonderful character to life. His ability to carry scenes with his charismatic acting skills is the crux of this series. I love seeing him in this role, and his interactions with his castmates are something I always look forward to.
Kim So Yeon as Ryu Hong Joo
Ryu Hong Joo is Yeon’s childhood friend. At one time she was the guardian spirit of the western mountain. In 1938, she runs the best high-end restaurant in the area. She has always had a crush on Yeon, and when she hear that he is in town, she is determined to finally win his heart. But she soon finds herself caught in the middle of a fight between Yeon and her other childhood friend, Moo Young. And her best solution seems to be stealing the ancient treasures for herself and getting away before either of them has any idea. But Yeon has other plans for their powerful trio, and he hopes to use Hong Joo to his advantage, so he can get back to the present on time and go back to his normal life.
Hong Joo is bold and powerful. But she also has a soft, protective heart. As a child, that need to protect extended to Yeon and Moo Young. But now it encompasses all the girls who work and live with her, as well as her loyal bodyguard, Jae Yoo. The addition of Hong Joo to this season was absolutely brilliant. Her character is fiery and outspoken. And there is just enough romantic tension on her part to make up for Yeon’s lack of an onscreen love interest. I loved Kim So Yeon in this part. She is a pleasure to watch and I love seeing her strong female charisma.
Supporting Characters
Kim Bum as Lee Rang
Lee Rang is Yeon’s half brother, which also makes him half nine-tailed fox and half human. In 2020, Rang sacrificed his own life to save Yeon. So getting to see Rang in 2020 is a highlight for Yeon, who has never stopped trying to find a way to bring him back. In 1938, Rang is operating as the boss of a ring of thieves. He also meets a half-blood mermaid at a local nightclub. When she falls instantly in love with him, Rang feels that he has finally met a kindred spirit. And since nine-tailed foxes only love 1 women in their lifetimes, he takes their connection very seriously.
Ryu Kyung Soo as Cheon Moo Young
Cheon Moo Young was Yeon’s other childhood friend and mountain god. But when Yeon kills Moo Young’s older brother, Moo Young vows revenge on his old friend. It is his stealing of the guardian stone that lures Yeon back to 1938 in the first place. Moo Young has always had a crush on Hong Joo, but she only saw Yeon. Now that they are all back together, Moo Young is hoping to show Hong Joo his sincere feelings for her.
Hwang Hee as Gu Shin Joo
Like Yeon, Gu Shin Joo is a mythical fox. The pair met and became fast friends. When Yeon is called back into the past, he brings Shin Joo as backup. Initially they get separated, but luckily Shin Joo finds his way back to Yeon. But his biggest shock in 1938 comes when he meets a daring young journalist who looks exactly like his wife in 2020.
Things I Liked
♥ Relationships
Ultimately this drama is driven by the fun characters and their chaotic energy. It gives us romance, family, and friendship backed by witty dialogue and touching interactions. And many of these characters get a chance to shine as we learn their strengths, weaknesses, and limitations. Whether you love Rang’s innocent bravado, Hong Joo’s spicy determination, Yeon’s sly “foxness” or any of the other interesting counterparts, it is the characters that keep us coming back to this drama. And the endless onscreen combinations are always enntertaining.
♥ Myths
This drama really pulled out an endless amount of myths and legendary figures, both Korean and Japanese. I always enjoy learning about new myths that I have never heard of, so I really enjoyed this element of the series. In the original drama, I heard people complaining about how the lead was more like an ordinary man than a mythological character. But I felt like in this second installment, we are never allowed to forget that all of these characters hold some magical powers that make their situations unique and interesting.
♥ Humor
For me, the touches of humor in this drama were perfectly delivered. It’s hard to pick a favorite moment, although I did especially love the “Three Men and a Baby” routine. I found myself continually giggling because of their crazy antics. And while it could have been cheesy in the hands of lesser writers and actors, it never got old for me. I think the decison to move away from a heavier romantic theme in favor of more fun moments was one of the things that made this prequel so much more enjoyable for me.
Things I Didn’t Like
Past/Present Connection
I found the whole disregard for the past timeline and how changes to the past may effect the present to be kind of strange in this drama. Many of these characters, such as Rang, are characters we have met and feel like we know. So how do you explain the fact that he had already met the love of his life by 2020 when we first met him. And how does Eun Ho fit into the present day story? Is Yoo Ri a reincarnation of her or are they just mysterious doppelgangers? And if the 1938 Yeon is now hanging out with Moo Young, than he shouldn’t have any need to travel back in time in the present. The whole timeline concept is just kind of a mess.
Moo Young’s Brother
This whole time travel scenario starts because of Moo Young’s plan to get revenge on Yeon and revive his dead brother. But the whole brother story kind of gets buried in the fight with countless villains and mini-villains. It seemed strange that when the moment actually came and Moo Young found out it wasn’t his brother that he revived, he just kind of dropped it without ever looking back. I’m pretty sure the writers are saving the original mountain god story for a Part 3. But that doesn’t change the fact that Moo Young technically lost his brother a second time. But he doesn’t even seem to mourn his loss. And why does he suddenly decide to just forgive Yeon for his part in his brother’s death?
Weak Villains
This drama gave us a steady stream of villains. But the one thing they all had in common was that when push came to shove, they were all pretty easy to beat. Their powers felt wildly inconsistent. They would seem almost unbeatable for a time and then some magic switch would flip and they would be taken out without much fanfare. Even Satori and Ryuhei, who were supposed to be legendarily unstoppable, both went down with a quiet whimper. Given the build up for these showdowns, I just expected more nail-biting suspense.
The Ending
“Tale of the Nine-Tailed 1938” gives us plenty of happy endings. Yeon gets the guardian stone and races back to the door to the present just in time, as a nervous Taluipa paces nearby. After pausing for a final, emotional goodbye with Rang, he and Shin Joo hop back into the present and all is well in both the past and the present. A follow up scene gives us an update into life in 1938 after Yeon’s visit. Hong Joo has gone back to running the restaurant, and her employees worry that she is drowning her sorrows in food. Moo Young has decided to become the person Hong Joo always saw him as, by practicing medicine as a traveling doctor among the poor of the city. Later we see the 1938 version of Yeon, flanked by his best friends, Moo Young and Hong Joo, as they fight against the Japanese who are threatening their city. And in the present, we see Yeon finally meeting up with Ji Ah. The couple embrace under his umbrella. The fox is home with his one true love.
Should I Watch
“Tale of the Nine-Tailed 1938” is a fantasy drama with large doses of humor and a bit of romance and mystery. For those who may be wondering, while this is technically a prequel, I don’t think it is absolutely necessary to have seen the original to enjoy this drama. The holes are filled in enough for you to get the general idea. I am in the minority in saying that I didn’t love the original “Tale of the Nine-Tailed” series. But I do not seem alone in saying that this sequel was definitely better than it’s predecessor. The strength in this drama lies in the interesting characters and their often comedic interactions. The abundance of mythological figures and fables are intriguing and unique. Unfortunately, while the characters are memorable and the collage of mini-plots is fun to watch, the series lacked any real cohesive plot. I was often left wondering where the story was supposed to be going. But the themes of love, friendship, and family are heartwarming and it has plenty of laughter along the way. I give “Tale of the Nine-Tailed 1938” an 8 out of 10 ramen.
🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜🍜